I am not sure what to think of the menace - it is definitely gimmicky, but have one that weighs 3.1 and it is very good. For its price, have seen some with lovely grains on them, I think mine has something like 12 or so, almost straight with a little heartwood. It is actually a lovely looking bat from the front. The only thing is that toe is real thin, and I am always worried when it might snap. I thought using a bat over 3lb was supposed to make you stop worrying about such things.
Newbery used to make a B52 xl that was pretty heavy, not sure if they do anything that big anymore.