Cheaper option is buy a dense Kashmir willow bat and see if it is worse. In theory lower density willow should be *better* for a variety of theoretical reasons but the final product of a variable material and process is exactly that. A guy I net with picked up the cheapest Kashmir bat he liked the stickers of in the local sports shop and ball comes off that thing better than any bat I've seen. Probably a bit of a freak but still shows bats are pretty individual things *
Back on topic, silly price for a bit of wood but if it makes someone happy then hey
* unless we talk about GM consistency
No reason why a Kashmir willow bat cant ping as good as a English willow, if pressed correctly. Is like the people who have experimented with Canadian and similar types of willow.
In my experience, Canadian willow is some of the best performing willow running around, it however has the draw back of a lack of durability, i bought a few a couple of years back, they performed as good as anything, some lasted 6 months, some lasted 6 days but never could fault the performance of the bat in any way.
At the end of the day we all have opinions and theories and this is why we are on the forum, is one view better than the other, in some instances but everyone will want different things.