Not this again. Firstly you haven't given the bat a chance, you haven't set it up like the other bat, (in terms of the grips) you have prepared it properly in terms of knocking in and playing in, and then you bound in making complaints and suggestive comments similar to another thread suggesting in some way the bat isn't correct and you have done all this in a public arena before talking to the bat maker. Firstly prepare your bat properly, then set them up all the same and if something isn't as you would expect speak to the maker privately rather than having a public discussion about a well regarded maker.
I think you have just read between the lines a bit too much
He hasn't at any time said one is rubbish, he was just, as he said, giving a subjective opinion, which is perfectly allowed
Please don't see any malice in this, the forum doesn't need another argument. I'm just standing up for the original poster here