What about it doesn't feel right? Depending on why it's not right would depend on what you may need to alter, surely?
I’ve done this a few times with SB LH bats. Cut the majority of the (No Swearing Please) off leaving a few mm so the binding doesn’t start coming apart Then used layered cut strips of grip to remake the (No Swearing Please) at the top of the handle, one of them remains my best bat ever. Never had any issues.