Interesting Leo. at our club, those who wish to stand put their names forward, but then the Cricket Action Group (CAG) decides. The CAG consists of Chairman, 1's/2's/3's/sundays skippers, cricket developement officer and not sure who else. The thinking is that if it goes to a member vote it becomes a popularity contest, and players from different teams vote on captains they don't really know...
What they don't realise is that they have created a closed shop with no f'ing stock!!