Lets be honest here. . . there are members on this forum. . .who could describe themselves as bat geeks. . .we are spoilt . . .constantly being shown very nice looking bats. Take Redbacks, Talismans or Saf's, they all look the part too. . . .when was the last time u saw an ugly'ish one of these. when ordering the reserve, i turned down quite a few clefts, based on looks. you start to get a feel for grade 1 or top grade bat, when you;ve seen so many on a daily basis. i am of the opinion that reserve must be perfomance based rather than looks. the clefts that i was shown didnt meet my standards im afraid.