Found an old video, while making the same bat:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oRd1K661apM&feature=youtu.be
It probably will answer your question why no shavings... perhaps it is my inefficiency to use the tool properly .
I used to request my wife to take these pictures and videos but no more.. but it seems like I should request her again... .
My bat making efficiency has no doubt improved and my choice of tools ( which tool to use when and where) is unconventional due to lack of training.
I will try to make a comprehensive video, next time I will make a bat.
After that video I am astounded you can create those types of bat in the pics... You must be better then Oscar at sanding!
Your plane needs a bloody good sharpen and you use the draw knife upside down...
As you mentioned you have problems with the shoulder shaping that method, upside down draw knife, can be used on there but for someone starting, even though you finished product confusingly very good:o, it isnt recommended. It is easier to use a spokeshave on the shoulder mount the bat on the vice so the edge is facing the ceiling...
I've yet to see the travisher you use?
But this is really important everything needs to be sharp