I think this is where Slazenger and GN have been quite clever though, both the V12 and the Dynadrive were around when I was a teenager, and were really desirable bats due to the pros using them back then. By re-releasing them 20 years on they've effectively tapped into the market of people who saw their school day heroes using them. Obviously with the advances in the game the bats aren't the same, but the name still carries the same magic.
Being someone who had both a V12 and a Dynadrive and the club bag had the Scoop, I got the idea behind the release, but the delivery of the V12 was very disappointing. It didn't have the shape which was what the V12 was all about, and the stickers are akin to the V Classic. However lovely the V12 is, it isn't a V12 for me (and neither is the V1200 a V1200!).
Both the Scoop and the Dynadrive are much more what they were supposed to be (in that they are essentially the classic bats made using modern techniques), even if GN have gone for stickers rather than paint....