I like my traditional looking stickers on a bat, however there is no finesse or style in these. The writing/design looks like it's been created in paint and it's stretched too much. If you're going to do something this simple it needs to be classy similar to the Newbery Kudos with a touch of colour. It would look much better if it was engraved as it adds texture and extra work.
The nicest thing is the background print which looks interesting.