West indies is a strange odi said in terms of batting personal.
Ignore the absence of pollard and bravo (there maybe evidence for dropping pollard. But in 2014 bravo was head and shoulder and above rest. And look at what's picked.
Ramdin imo is batting to high. 6 at most. Probably a 7. Definately not a top 5.
Sammy at 7. Seems to bowl very little sometimes not at all. So he's being picked as a batsmen. A good hitter who can win a game. But is he really in the top 6/7 batsmen available?
Gayle. Great to watch. And a must in t20. But in the linger format, does his inability to run not put pressure on everyone else in the team??