I bought a Dwayne Smith edition SF bat a few weeks ago from OLS. When the bat arrived, it was an ounce and a half heavier than what I ordered (no huge deal as it picks up pretty well), but had some stickers on the back that I hadn't seen before on any reviews. When I rolled the grip off to change to an octopus, it had "Optimus" written on the handle in thick pen. When I emailed OLS asking about this (the DS model is $40 dearer) he assured me it was all fine and definitely genuine. he said the stickers were the new 2015 stickers (the same excuse he used when I bought an SS Platinum off him last time).
I have just checked the handle after reading this thread and mine also too has a nail in the handle near the top of the handle.
It is a real pity as it has spoiled the experience of getting a bat that absolutely pings! I'm keeping the bat but only because I can't be bothered with the stress of trying to return it.
I will, however, never buy from him again and will be telling all that listen about his refusal to assist customers with concerns.