Do you guys think there is merit to Steven Smith's approach? He take middle-stump guard and basically swats everything on off to the leg side. Cook and Amla are predominantly leg/on-side players. Smith has few off-side shots.
I think I watched a video of Bob Woolmer coaching, and he said something along the lines of:
'If you like to play on the leg side, you should take a middle stump guard. If you're greedy, and like scoring all round the wicket, you should take a middle-leg guard. If you're predominantly an off side player, you should take a leg stump guard to give yourself that extra bit of room to free your arms.'
If something is a weakness, then leave it in a match situation and improve on it by first mentally going through the shot, visualising what kind of a line and length you're going to play the shot off, then groove the shot through shadow batting and underarm feeds, then bowling machine. If I had the time to do it, this would probably be my approach. Yes, you may get out a few times at the beginning, but it's about building confidence in the shot. What works for Smith/Cook won't necessarily work for you!
I basically received a rectal examination on a fast and bouncy track at Tynedale on Sunday, where their opening bowler kept bowling a channel outside off and just short of a length. Kept having to leave, and ended up scoring 2 runs off 12 deliveries from him. (The runs came from a ball on the stumps) I'm a bit of a front foot bully, which I'm looking to change up, as with more attacking batting being on demand due to the professional game, I'd like to make runs off as many types of deliveries as possible! (Games at my level have also been reduced to 40 overs a side, which makes 200 a par score)