Of course you are both right, he will never play for England again, and apologies for anyone who is miffed the thread is slightly off subject, it's not deliberate.....
There are a lot of fans who think he should still be playing, and there's a lot of us fans who think he should'nt and are really really happy with the current England side.
I've followed England since i was about 13 and that's a long time ago, and I'm optimistic we are getting where we want to be and in a good position with other players in the wings...having a good coach helps and we have two in farbrace and Bayliss-bringing on and developing young talent.
KP actually does have more of a chance playing for SA. If you think about it SA have had a few top class players retire at the same time.
The idea of Pieterson playing for them is not as daft as it may seem
And he would not be the only player to play for two Countries...
Just my opinion on it