@Manormanic I like some of your thinking, you young shaver! Personally, I'd slot YJB in to the no 5 slot and pick a keeper to bat 7 - who are the current contenders though?
Thats the issue really, who is there in County Cricket?
Read, Wallace and Foster, all quality glovemen, are too old to be serious contenders, as is Tim Ambrose. The only other top quality specialists in the county game are a long way short as batsmen (Bates) or can't get in the Yorkshire side (Hodd).
Of the keeping all rounders, I think we have to rule Buttler and Billings out for now due to the IPL, and Davies and Duckett out because they do not hold the gloves for their current counties. That leaves Ben Foakes, Adam Wheater, John Simpson and Ben Brown...
None are particularly convincing, though the England management clearly like Foakes because they have given him a lot of exposure in A squads and as 12th man for hte main side. You suspect they might be behind him getting the gloves off of the excellent Gary Wilson at Surrey too...
How about the test side for late 2017 eh?
Cook
Lees
Compton
Root
Bairstow
Stokes
Duckett
Curran
Crane
Finn
Footitt
Not sure I see that side turning out, certainly not that soon. Lees needs a big season for Yorkshire, Curran (assuming you mean Tom rather than Sam) has a lot of people to get past and Footitt's time has probably been and gone. There is a lot to get excited about though, especially if their counties help Duckett, Crane etc to develop into the players England need.