Proven performer? He averages 24 this year. I wouldn't be selecting him on his performances
Looks like he needs a break? He hasn't done anything to deserve a break.. he deserves to be dropped
Call it what you like but Jason Roy is far from done at international level, he will play plenty more ODI and t20 cricket. His average this year when in the worst form of his life is still considerably higher than Henriques career average. Henriques genuinely wouldn't get in Englands 2nd XI
If they do bring in Bairstow now for Roy (which I think they should, Roy looks mentally shot) it has to be a straight swap, at least for the remainder of this tournament. The middle order has been firing pretty well and Moeen Ali for all his qualities I dont think is cut out to open at the top level