Been at both businesses numerous times, and own probably more of each than most people's collections. Rob, James and Matt are exceptional craftsmen, and very knowledgeable in batmaking. I've watched batmaking in both stables, James. (If I could get some time to edit the videos, I'd share!) I don't think you could go wrong on a RPC Players Grade or H4L G1. Personally, if I was going for something a little more traditional shaped, I'd probably go to RPC - especially if you're a fan of the old Millichamp styled shapes. H4L if I'm after something modern - they can produce pretty big volumed bats, but since you're after a 2lb 7oz - 2lb 9oz, it might not be quite to your. (For context, I'm currently using a 2.11 traditional styled bat from RPC in matches, felt incredible in the nets but not been scoring any runs, but down to batsman error rather than anything else
)
What I'm currently using:
Rob's old Puma Ballistic shape (Was inspired by the JM Classic shape):
Rob's modern/classic blend:
Rob's take on a GM Watto Players (With hint of concaving):
James' take on an England International Player's bat. (Not sure if I can mention who's)
James' take on a JM Screaming Cat on steroids, with a round face press (Spine is approx 70mm):
H4L Monster Root (Cause who better than someone who had made some of Root's back in GM?):
James' take on the old Gray Nics Monster James Taylor (F18):
All of these are probably well above your weight range (Especially the H4Ls), but should give an idea of what you'd be getting.