12 Reviews of Christmas...
Advertise on CBF

Pages: [1] 2 3

Author Topic: 12 Reviews of Christmas...  (Read 4494 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Chad

12 Reviews of Christmas...
« on: December 26, 2022, 01:03:21 AM »

Dammit, I think I might have missed the cut-off due to the forum connection preventing my post, and then making me start all over again  :( ... But oh gosh... Why am I doing this again...



My aim for this year's series is hopefully going to be a review a day, which will be split between providing a little insight into what's available at retailers and what I found in general when browsing the particular range being reviewed, and also some reviews on bats made by independent batmakers. Please drop me a PM if I've missed anything that you'd like to see or hear about - I will be locking this topic until I've completed the series. (Not because my view is more powerful than yours or whatever has been said recently about my bat cupboard size)

On the first day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...

A Gray Nicolls Hypernova!


 


 























Model: Hypernova 1.0 4 Star
Willow Grade: G2/3
Weight: 2lb 9oz
Edge Max: 38-39mm
Spine Max: 66-67mm
Toe Edge: 22-23mm
Toe Centre: 28mm
Shoulder Edge: 13mm
Splice Depth: 37mm
Concaving: Minimal
Width: 107-108mm
Face Camber: Semi-Round (Interesting, as the GN website description suggests they're meant to be flat)
Handle: Good thickness oval bottom hand tapering to a semi-oval top hand
Toe shape: Square




Right, so it's been so long since I've done this that I've no idea where to start with this...

But I may as well start off with the range that has impressed me the most upon travelling around numerous retailers - the Gray Nicolls Hypernova! I must have seen more than 40 Hypernova bats, and everything that really matters about a good solid cricket bat seemed to be ticked. The bats all seemed to perform to a satisfactory level, the playing area size seemed to be large on those that I had a chance to tap up with a mallet or ball and the pick ups all felt pretty balanced. The lower grades by in large seemed to offer some rather excellent value for money as well.



This particular bat was a stand out, alongside a Players grade Hypernova at the Romida Hemel Hempstead store. (Had an excellent shopping experience there) You would say the grading based on aesthetics has been very fair - if not a touch generous, considering the 4 star model lies below the Pro Performance, Players and 5 Star grades. With 7 pretty clean and straight grains with just a blemish towards the toe area of the bat. As you can see from the photos, the bat is definitely rather voluminous, filling out the gauge generously. There is no noticeable width sacrifice, nor a stick thin handle to keep the weight down. The profile itself is a mid-low swell (Approx 185mm from the toe) with a gentle duckbill and the spine running fairly high into the handle - retaining a good amount of wood in splice area, while taking off enough at the toe to help with the balance and pick up. The pressing feels very good on the Gray Nicolls bats - with a them feeling nice and supple, but not too soft, so they shouldn't take a long knocking in time. This particular one feels like it will perform very well up and down the blade, while offering the best value for shot in the mid-low section. Hopefully once knocked, I'll take it for a twirl in the nets and update this.


I know the stickers definitely aren't for everyone - in flesh, the detailing is very nice, and the colours are very striking. The red, black, yellow and navy definitely do stand out, and is actually a very nice colour combo. I would say that it would look a lot cleaner without the back stickers - they almost look like a dragon's tail or some horns. If sticker colours do matter to you, maybe you'll find the 1.1 or 1.3 versions more palatable - the 1.3 green and silver is bound to be a big hit amongst the Pakistani supporters, and the 1.1 is definitely a lot less garish (blue and silver) than the 1.0 colourway. Stock wise, the 1.0 and the 1.3 versions seemed far more commonplace, (The 1.0 was the most widely available across all grades) and I think I may have seen 1 or 2 1.1. As cool as it is to have different colourways for a range, it's definitely a bit of a headache for retailers, as in some way, they've kind of got to take an extra factor into consideration when ordering stock.







Bonus Pics:


A lovely 5 Star 1.0 (2lb 11oz) compared to a lovely 300 1.3 (2lb 10oz) - highlighting the slight variations you'll have due to handmaking (Swell on the 1.3 is lower) and also the differences in sticker colourways











The Players Grade pearler in Romida Hemel Hempstead




 
« Last Edit: December 28, 2022, 12:09:04 AM by Chad »
Logged

Chad

Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #1 on: December 27, 2022, 01:27:02 AM »

On the second day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...


A Gunn & Moore 606 Brava!


   


   
























Model: Brava 606
Willow Grade: G3
Weight: 2lb 10oz
Edge Max: 38mm
Spine Max: 61mm
Toe Edge: 23mm
Toe Centre: 28mm
Shoulder Edge: 14mm
Splice Depth: 35mm
Concaving: None
Width: 107-108mm
Face Camber: 2mm Flatter face
Handle: Nice thick oval tapering to quite a thin round handle
Toe shape: Semi-rounded





The GM Brava - one of my most anticipated stock shaped bats of the year. With a rather elongated swell, and what appeared to be plenty of wood in the hitting zones and a relatively thick toe, I felt that GM were onto a winner. I'm not the biggest fan of flat faces, I do feel they cause a few more issues while offering a weight saving benefit for perceived volume. When they were first introduced, as someone who certainly doesn't centre every ball, the twist felt wasn't pleasant, but at least the bat gave good feedback when you didn't quite centre the ball. According to GM, weights start around 2lb 10oz, however I did find an 808 as light as 2lb 7.5oz!


In terms of the Bravas that I saw in stock across retailers - I was actually a little disappointed. The bats upon tapping up felt very hard, there was almost no give when doing so, and none of that solid with a hint of suppleness and depth I associate with well made GM bats. It was more of a rather tinny feel and sound, and the sweetspot sizes themselves felt rather small. However, that's not to say I didn't find some that were actually very nice out the packet - some of the 808s (2 outliers from Talent Cricket that were 2.7-2. 8) and an LE in Mr Cricket Hockey were very nice indeed - but for the £550 price tag for an LE bat - performance out the packet certainly should come as somewhat of a guarantee!


This particular Brava was obtained through eBay, and is no exception to my what I saw amongst the majority of the Brava range - hard, tinny/planky. The pick up is certainly very good for a 2.10, and with the small knots just barely on the surface on the back and the 5 wide grains with a slant - it isn't an absolute find or steal, but a fair grading/price for the entry level Brava. The shape is certainly very desirable to me, as it does offer a very nice volume throughout that hitting zone, and the spine blending into a toe with a good thickness. There is quite a small playing area from a low to a sort of mid position. Given that most bats do improve with time, I would expect this zone to increase in size with proper knocking and running in of the bat.


The branding and profile for the Brava feel spot on - the blue with a hint of gold definitely seem to compliment each other well, giving the bat a rather classical look. I did think GM might have pushed the boat out a little and redesigned the stickers, (Especially as I had felt the Sparq, Prima and revamped Icon stickers were not massively inspiring) but the colourways for the 3 models that have come out have been pretty spot on. I think the flat face is maybe something that I'm not a big fan of, but I can see why they've went with it while offering a fairly large volume bat for the market - dead weight does sell bats, and as much as I'd love to see some of these in the standard semi-round roller face, that would mean heavier weights.


To wrap things up - of course, despite the rather disappointing initial thoughts on this range, this can all completely change given time and playing in. Afterall, how are you really going to know how a bat will play in over its lifespan? And despite the disappointment, I did manage to find 3 particular examples out of maybe just over 10 which were very nice out the packet. Perhaps there was some bias against the range, as receiving this particular Brava before heading on my retailer visit may have set the tone. Perhaps it could be the result of re-introducing the flat face and maybe getting the pressing right for them. All I know is that if someone were to be looking for a Brava, I'd recommend calling some local retailers to see if they have any in stock before visiting and picking out one that feels good for you. (And fingers crossed for me that the one I've got coming from @Six Sixes Cricket is a pearler!)

Anyways, apologies again for the tardiness - I'll try do the next one on time!  :D




Bonus Pics - the 2 808s that were Pick Up Index 1 2.7-2.8 anomalies from Talent Cricket:





The one I nearly left with:



« Last Edit: December 28, 2022, 12:08:39 AM by Chad »
Logged

Chad

Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #2 on: December 28, 2022, 12:07:58 AM »

On the third day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...


A New Balance DC 580!




   

   























Model: DC 580
Willow Grade: G5
Weight: 2lb 8.6oz
Edge Max: 36mm one side, 38mm the other
Spine Max: 68mm
Toe Edge: 21mm
Toe Centre: 29mm
Shoulder Edge: 13-14mm
Splice Depth: 39mm
Concaving: Minimal from the sweetspot up to the splice, and moderate from the sweetspot down to where the spine ends as the toe flattens for the duckbill
Width: 109mm on the front, and 107mm on the back at some points, but basically not narrowed at all
Face Camber: 6-7mm traditional
Handle: Medium semi-oval/oval handle
Toe shape: Semi-rounded




Definitely not a brand I had really wanted to purchase based on catalogue images as the branding just didn't do it for me, but in person, the green and orange definitely caught my eye. The DC model in the New Balance range is intended for the Dynamic Cricketer, while the TC is more for the Traditional Cricketer. That being said, it does somewhat surprise me that the DC comes with a round face, mid-low swell with a duckbill while the TC, Burn and Heritage models seem to come with a flat face and quite a similar mid-high profile with the spines running into the toes. They somewhat reminded me of the introduction of the flat faces at Kookaburra with the Ricochet and Impulse(?) models, which weren't my taste.


In terms of New Balances I saw at retailers - the DC range just always stood out for me, they seemed to have a more desirable profile. The ones I did tap up from the TC and Burn ranges seemed to perform well across the range, but as I said, I seemed to take more of a liking to the DC range. The toes didn't seem overly skinny, and just the round face with the duckbill profile seemed to work for me. There were a fair few nice ones at All Rounder, and Talent Cricket had a fresh shipment the day I visited.


I actually got quite lucky with this one in that it came from the fresh batch at Talent Cricket, where the box was opened in front of me. I'll be completely honest, I picked this one purely in terms of size, the bat itself just looked big and felt quite nice and light. Responsiveness wise, it feels quite nice and supple, but definitely feels like it will need some mallet work before being taken to the nets. The willow itself has allowed for a pretty substantial hitting zone volume, while not really sacrificing too much in the toe or shoulder area, at least for modern standards. Definitely one of those ones where I wish they had just left an extra ounce of wood in the blade just to beef up that toe area a bit and keep a touch more in the shoulder, but naturally, when they're made in bulk, the biggest factor would be weight for a lot of retailers. For a grade 5 piece of willow, there really isn't a lot wrong with this piece aesthetic wise. There are 8 pretty clean straight grains, and also some wavy marks in the heartwood visible on the back just below the splice sticker, which is something I look for in willow, as every one I've had with those kind of marks seems to ping. The pick up feels lovely and light to me - with the duckbill and spine running through the splice pairing beautifully to allow for wood distribution to counteract that large mid-low swell.


Branding wise, I know the aesthetics won't do it for everyone, but I love the detail in matching the grip colours with the sticker colourway. The metallic dark-green/green and orange is definitely far less offensive to the eye than I initially felt, and there is some subtle detailing in the stickers if you have a close up look. The wrap around sticker and the edge stickers don't do it for me - perhaps some burnt in NB logo on the edge would have served well.


All in all, a solid offering from NB, especially at this price point, but I could have just gotten darn lucky. The All Rounder store at Penistone/Sheffield seemed to have a decent amount of stock (Albeit of last season's stock), the Headingley store was just a little too claustrophobic for me to have a proper look, and Talent did get a decent sized shipment if you're interested in this.




Logged

Chad

Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #3 on: December 28, 2022, 11:48:14 PM »

On the fourth day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...


A DSC Intense 4000!


   

   




















Model: Intense 4000
Willow Grade: G3
Weight: 2lb 9.7oz
Edge Max: 40mm
Spine Max: 67mm
Toe Edge: 27mm
Toe Centre: 32mm
Shoulder Edge: 14mm
Splice Depth: 38mm
Concaving: Very minimal
Width: 108mm
Face Camber: Semi-round (Around 4mm)
Handle: Medium oval tapering to round
Toe Shape: Rounded and angled




I don't think DSC get too much love here on the forum, they do seem to be churning out some excellent bats, and from what I remembered retailers saying, they seem to be quite popular amongst customers. Pretty large and attractive profiles, and plenty of different options at different price points, I do find them to be a rather fantastic offering, especially in the lower range end of the spectrum. They do seem to offer a bit of variety in their profiles across the range, although there's some similarity between the profiles, there are noticeable differences when examining the range as a whole.


In terms of the DSC I saw at retailers, Romida, Eclipse All Sports and All Rounder seemed to hold stock, and the bats at Eclipse certainly were very good, generally very consistent, with some real standouts and some ridiculous Players Editions. I didn't take so much interest in them across other stores like Romida and All Rounder, perhaps because I was so preoccupied with Gray Nicolls, Gunn and Moore, Chase etc when at those chains. Having dealt with DSC for a number of years now, Hanif from EAS mentioned that they were some of the most consistent in terms of producing performers regardless of grade. Some of the lower grades even have pretty much the same profile as the Players Editions, so definitely a brand worth looking into if you're going for retailer visits to pick out lower grades with a pretty ridiculous volume.


This particular bat was purchased from Eclipse All Sports - I've dealt with Hanif there for many years, and he's always sent me up excellent bats, so it's always a treat to go down and pick out my own and also have a wee chin-wag about cricket equipment in general. As you can see, it boasts a rather large profile without much compromise anywhere volume wise. That very evenly distributed mass with a minimal amount of concaving throughout the blade to keep the weight down results in a nicely balanced pick up, but you can feel that you've got a fair chunk of wood low down. It's not too dissimilar to the GM Brava, and actually reminds me of one of my favourite GM profiles - the GM Argon. Looks wise, you've got 8 pretty straight grains, albeit 2 pretty much running along the edge, and quite a bit of speckle, you'd say a fair G3. Responsiveness wise out the packet, the ball absolutely flies off the bat. Crazy, as it most definitely needs knocking, and speaking with Hanif, his experience is that they just get better with knocking.


Branding wise, the DSC aesthetic can be a bit loud for some - however it really does stand out on television. I really like the stickers myself, and the classy white grip with the 2 main colourways is a bit of icing on top, giving what is a bit loud and garish a little bit of a refined and cohesive end product aesthetic. (At least for me) The subtle detailing, embossing and textures help with making the stickers stand out more. While the bold colours will probably mostly attract the younger generation (or @FattusCattus ) - I feel there is also a good amount of wood shown to maybe sucker in some who prefer a slightly more minimalist look, especially without the old sticker that used to wrap round the back and edge.

Anyways, I had @19reading87 message me earlier, asking how the ping was on the Brava - so I'm clearly typing out far too much and folks are probably getting a bit lost in the text - apologies. I have been doing this while a bit under the weather, but I'll try split out the sections a little more, and maybe not waffle so much...
Logged

Chad

Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #4 on: December 31, 2022, 02:09:38 AM »

On the fifth day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...


A WCW 5 Star Orca!


   


   




























Model: Orca 5 Star
Willow Grade: G2/3?
Weight: 2lb 9.4oz
Edge Max: 38mm
Spine Max: 62mm
Toe Edge: 22mm
Toe Centre: 27mm
Shoulder Edge: 13mm
Splice Depth: 37mm

Concaving: None
Width: 108mm
Face Camber: Semi-round (Around 5mm)
Handle: Semi-Oval
Toe Shape: Slightly rounded


A bit of a change up, one of the smaller, less mainstream brands for today. World Class Willow offer 2 main stock profiles, the Pro X20 and Orca, and if you're feeling rich, there is the Chaos model, used by Will Smead and made using the lowest density pieces of willow, coming in at £725. There's also a new Storm profile coming out, which should incorporate the shorter blade of the Pro X20 and the slightly higher swell of the Orca. They have also made it into retail, and were a particular brand I was keen on viewing when visiting retailers.

I believe I saw a grand total of 6 at the retailers, with a mixture of their Pro X20 and their Orca models. And if I'm completely honest - if those were the only 6 I'd ever seen, I would be put off buying a WCW. Hidden behind the really wonderful stickers were some rather slap dash bits of finishing to cricket bats, with electric planer marks along the edge not being blended out with sanding, the generally smooth and sheen finish present on most retail bats from reputable manufacturers was instead a rather grainy feeling finish - almost as if no compound was used for buffing. There was one that was actually finished to an acceptable standard - but that was riddled with storm damage. A massive let down for me personally, as I had picked certain retailers to visit because they were meant to stock these. (Scotland is a fair bit away from any retailers who stock WCW) That being said, they all seemed to be solidly pressed, and pick ups were decent on them.

That being said, this particular one was obtained via @JTtaylor145 on eBay, and actually wasn't the one I was meant to bid for, but it is the one I ended up with. It does ping pretty nicely, but not quite nearly as nice as the Pro X20 I have - most likely because of the extra weight packed into that particular bat. The profile pretty much caters to what a large proportion of the market wants - attractive big edges, a good sized spine spine height with no concaving. The hitting zone is a good size, with most value coming from the mid to low sections of the bat. Higher up the blade, there isn't quite as much responsiveness, possibly due to the way the spine dips shortly after the peak rather than sweeping up and gradually dropping off. The pick up is balanced, and despite being full profiled, there isn't that hint of bottom heaviness you often feel with modern full profiled bats. There are some swirl marks in the finish - it is going to happen fairly often if the orbital sander is what you use, but the presentation of the bat is miles better than the ones I had seen on retailers shelves.


Branding wise - one of the most stand out new brands to hit the shelves at certain retailers, and certainly some of the most stand out graphics. (And IMO the best on the market) They do 3 different colourways for their Pro X20 and Orca ranges - the Orbit, Sunset and Caribbean. The fusion of colours give a rather stand out look from a distance, but retaining a classiness when coupled with the prismatic ink, the subtle repeated etching of the WCW logo across the entire sticker and texturing - all details that you can appreciate up close. You can check on their website to see what the other stickers are like - this particular example is the Sunset. The Flair, Storm and Chaos all have their own unique colourways.


Although the sample size was small for me, hopefully this gives a rough idea of whether you should buy blind or not. Personally, I know they're capable of churning out a far better end product than what I had observed in retail (This one is an example of that), so perhaps an in person visit at the factory is required.


http://custombats.co.uk/cbforum/index.php?topic=49953.0 - The review for the Pro X20 5 Star mentioned.
Logged

Chad

Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #5 on: December 31, 2022, 03:23:17 AM »

On the sixth day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...

A Red Ink Zaras X3!

   


   

























Model: Zaras X3
Willow Grade: G3/Butterfly
Weight: 2lb 11oz
Edge Max: 30mm
Spine Max: 60mm
Toe Edge: 24mm
Toe Centre: 27mm
Shoulder Edge: 17mm
Splice Depth: 39mm
Concaving: Minimal
Width: 108-109mm
Face Camber: Flatter (Around 3mm)
Handle: Good thickness oval bottom hand tapering to a round top hand
Toe shape: Rounded and slightly angled

Continuing with the change up, this time with a boutique brand - our very own Red Ink! John @Red Ink Cricket  has been a sponsor of this forum since as far back as I can remember. He has been making bats for just about over a decade I believe, and is still churning out some very nice bats from what I've seen.


I can't comment too much on bats that he'll have in stock, as I've never visited - this particular bat was actually used in his photoshoot for the profiles and stickers. However, the shopping experience itself was grand - sorry if I was a pain at all John, but you were great. I also nearly picked up the other profiles, but I behaved as I did end up buying some part mades instead :D


This particular bat is a stock shape, and a rather refreshing one at that. The edge profile itself is more akin to the traditional style - with a modest but strong edge throughout the blade. The flatter face does allow for a larger perceived profile, and the high spine (relative to the edge) sweeps into the handle, and drops off and flattens into the toe, giving the bat a lightweight pickup. The press is pretty damn solid - the ball absolutely flies off the mid to high sections, while the performance seems to taper off at the low end of the bat - big fan of the response, and it doesn't feel like it will need much prep at all. The bow is also something worth mentioning - it is a pretty heavily bowed blade. The finishing is excellent - the bat has picked up a few dings here and there, and also put on an ounce in the Scottish Winter, but has still retained the sheen. There are some orbital marks around the swell at the back, but that's just what comes with sanding those areas at times! Looks wise, you've got got 8 pretty damn straight and even clean grains with 2 very small marks at the toe and the edge - had it not been for the butterfly, this would have probably been a G1 bat. For me though, I personally love how the dark stain of the butterfly seems to compliment the product as a whole - I personally just love the character it brings out and think it contrasts well with the turquoise stickers.

Sticker wise, they're definitely a little more on the minimalist side, but a very solid design. (I believe the same chap who designed WCW did these too) The embossing and texturing do add to the visuals, and I personally love the colour. I will say that I'm not too sure about the red, grey and white grip - I think these pair nicely with the Theos and the Sirius stickers, maybe a white grip with a hint of turquoise would pair nicer with this bat, and maybe even the Pyro.


All in all, massively impressed by the offering from John. Yes, this particular bat might not be quite as big spec wise compared to some other modern bats, but everything else from the pressing, shaping, balancing and finishing are spot on. Getting a bespoke service for £205 as an entry level and £430 at the top end of this quality represents excellent value for money in the modern market. (Having had part mades as well, the pressing on those are pretty much spot on, which is what I'm basing my judgement on) I should also add that I'm sad I checked out the Instagram page as well for some of the details, as I found out they had a Black Friday sale 😂
« Last Edit: December 31, 2022, 03:39:19 AM by Chad »
Logged

Chad

Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #6 on: January 01, 2023, 07:50:14 PM »

On the seventh day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...


A Gray Nicolls Xiphos 300


   


   

























Model: Xiphos 300
Willow Grade: G3
Weight: 2lb 9.6oz
Edge Max: 37-38mm
Spine Max: 64.5mm
Toe Edge: 21mm
Toe Centre: 26mm
Shoulder Edge: 14-15mm
Splice Depth: 38-39mm
Concaving: Scoops out the back
Width: 106-107mm
Face Camber: Semi-rounded. (Approx 5mm)
Handle: Oval
Toe Shape: Rounded




Back to the more mainstream brands, and here is a GN Xiphos - I remember this bat as a kid, and thinking it looked pretty darn awesome with the graphics and the scoops cut out. The Phoenix and the Kookaburra Genesis were 2 of the earliest bats I owned, so this bat did stand out for me - however I didn't quite have the funds back then to purchase. I didn't see too many of these available at retailers, but there were probably about 5-10 that I saw on my visits, so some did have stock. This particular one was picked up at VKS in London - the shopping experience there wasn't quite my cup of tea, but they had a fair bit of stock, and when I eventually met @VKS  Vinay he was super pleasant to deal with himself.


This particular bat 5 very clean grains on the face, with a 6th just running along the edge. The shape itself provides a good weight distribution and plenty of mass in the hitting zone, and by removing the wood via scoops closer to the edge, I'm guessing the idea was to have the wood packed into the middle like a full profiled bat, while having the weight and pick up characteristics of a concave bat by removing the wood where you shouldn't need it. The result is a very sweet hitting zone and a well balanced pick up, with me noticing just a hint of bottom heaviness. The finishing is pretty good, as it tends to be with Gray Nicolls bats, however the scoops are a little bit rough. (Must add I think it must be a royal pain in the ass the try finish these scoops well, especially when in a mass manufacturing setting, so I don't blame them)


Branding and profile wise, this release is pretty faithful to the originals, but doesn't have that swoop leading into the handle, as pictured side by side below, and also doesn't have a fully round face camber. You'd also say the older versions have a little bit more wood low down, but that would be nitpicking. The slight update in stickers is welcome, with it being both faithful to the originals and also cohesive with their retro range, with the model sticker shape and also the detailing on the red stickers. All in all, an excellent retro release, and certainly by far the superior choice amongst the 2 retros released this year due to the accessibility with 2 grades, and also in terms of execution.











Logged

Chad

Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #7 on: January 02, 2023, 01:34:06 AM »

On the eighth day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...


A GM Hypa Signature!

   


   






















Model: Hypa Signature
Willow Grade: G2/3
Weight: 2lb 11oz
Edge Max: 35-36mm
Spine Max: 58mm
Toe Edge: 21mm
Toe Centre: 26mm
Shoulder Edge: 12mm
Splice Depth: 36mm
Concaving: None
Width: 108mm
Face Camber: Semi-round - 4.5mm
Handle: Thick oval tapering into a round top hand
Toe Shape: Rounded




Now onto probably my favourite of the GM releases when viewing in person - the Hypa! When I first saw this on the release, I wasn't too sure about it with that crazy sort of popping effect with the multi-coloured outline, but credit to GM, I feel that it really makes the model stand out. The mid-low profile is one which should prove pretty popular with the low bounce decks we have here in the UK, and a decent amount of thickness in the toe should hopefully help reduce the chances of blowing the toe off. (Still, try to avoid smashing off any toes!) For those who remember the GM Halo and GM Aura - I'd say this profile is very much of that sort of family of profiles. (Halo I think had spine into toe and Aura had a slightly higher swell)


Onto why it's probably my favourite of the GM releases - the consistency of rebound across the grades seemed to be excellent, as well as their pick ups. I don't really recall seeing a poor one, and I saw a good number of these in retailers - pretty much every retailer had some stock. Most retailers had found that the Hypa range had done really well, and they seemed to be outselling the Diamonds for some.


This particular bat was obtained via eBay from @JTtaylor145 - who admits to me he regrets letting this one go. It has a typical harder feel that is associated with GM, but feels very responsive - there is that bit of suppleness when testing the rebound with ball, and the bat feels like it's ready to take into the nets. The strike zone from low to mid is very responsive, with the responsiveness dying off after the mid-high zone, which is to be expected with the taper in the swell towards the handle. The pick up is beautifully balanced, thanks to the thick oval handle which helps as a counterbalance to all the mass low down the blade. The 8 grains with a slight wobble, the odd blemish and some heartwood is quite typical of the Signature/707 grade, so I'd say this was fairly graded, but a decent standout example due to the grain structure and relative cleanness of the blade.


Branding wise, I think I've mentioned that it is quite standout, especially in person. It gives a sort of 3D pop-out effect,  I love that the coloured strips around the top of the grip match the colourway, which is a really nice touch to add for detailing. The grip design itself is a zigzag style grip, which after initial feel, I'm quite a big fan of. It seems to offer pretty good grip, but without the abrasiveness of the Hex Grip. All in all, the product itself might not appeal to everyone, but is something different and pretty standout. Perhaps upon noticing it from the corner of their eye and picking it up in the shops, a typically minimalist-oriented consumer will be hooked with the attractiveness of the profile and pick up.




Hypa vs Noir:








« Last Edit: January 03, 2023, 03:03:08 PM by Chad »
Logged

Chad

Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #8 on: January 02, 2023, 08:31:25 PM »

On the ninth day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...


A Warsop Platinum! (With Inspire 152 Stickers)


   


   




























Model: Warsop Platinum
Willow Grade: G1/G1+
Weight: 2lb 11.7oz
Edge Max: 27mm
Spine Max: 62mm
Toe Edge: 21mm
Toe Centre: 31mm
Shoulder Edge: 14mm
Splice Depth: 39mm
Concaving: Convex
Width: 108mm (109mm at some points, and 106mm at the shoulders)
Face Camber: Semi-round (Approx 5mm)
Handle: Oval Fish Fin
Toe Shape: Rounded




Something a little more old school today, this one is a classical shaped bat from Warsop. Funny story about this one, I had actually picked out a beautiful Warsop Platinum while visiting back in 2021. It was honestly sublime when picking up, the profile and everything about it was perfect, from the rounded traditional face and the grains and the feel of the handle. Unfortunately, it turned out that there was a defect I hadn't noticed when picking it up. (Due to COVID restrictions lifting slowly, Warsop had their bats in plastic bags, and the lighting wasn't the brightest inside) When I saw this, I dropped Clere at Warsop a message, and she called back being massively apologetic and surprised it had slipped through. Both her and Tony reckon it might have been one of the ones used for a Magazine test that happened to catch some damage.


This was the resultant replacement, another immaculately balanced piece, which was arguably even better looking. I swear they must have used one of the nicest pieces available for this. 9 straight and very clean grains with good spacing. A beautiful old school English profile, very much of the same ilk of profiles like the Purist, Mjolnir, Puma Classic and M&H Classic Low. A profile that answers to no gauge other than what the batmaker has gauged to be a solid bat. Working the willow and cane into a shape that seeks to optimise the inherent properties - balance, feel and performance. The result is a bat that feels dreamy in the hands, and a profile which offers plenty of coverage with a strong and rounded spine throughout the profile, and a good strong edge throughout. The pressing on this bat does result in a lovely sound when tapping up, and seam marks do suggest there is still some prep to do. The only complaint I really have is that the face isn't quite the old school round, but I was happy with this.


Branding wise, this has actually warmed to me. Yes, the stickers aren't of a high quality of the likes of GM, WCW and GN - they're not the most eye catching, nor do they have all the bells and whistles. While I would much prefer the old Cobra or Scimitar style stickers, the Red, Blue and White do give off the old school retro vibes. And while there is a slight knick of the edge here and there, the bat is finished pretty nicely, and I think they tend to leave the toes a little rough for toe guards. The rounded profile and white grip certainly match the aesthetic well, at least for me.


And looks wise, pretty much as nice as they come grain wise - there definitely is not much wrong with this. As I said, I do wonder if they used their Inspire quality of willow for this particular bat, or if their grading is just pretty darn generous. One of, if not THE oldest bat making brand still around, and also one of the best priced for willow quality.




Bonus pics: The one that I returned














« Last Edit: January 03, 2023, 10:10:19 AM by Chad »
Logged

Chad

Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #9 on: January 03, 2023, 10:45:24 PM »

On the tenth day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...


A Scott JS175! (And an on time review  :D [size=78%])[/size]


   


   


































Model: JS 175 G2/Butterfly
Willow Grade: G2 with Butterfly
Weight: 2lb 10.5oz
Edge Max: 38mm
Spine Max: 71mm
Toe Edge: 22-23mm
Toe Centre: 30mm
Shoulder Edge: 15-16mm
Splice Depth: 41mm
Concaving: Moderate
Width: 108mm
Face Camber: Semi-round (Approx 5mm)
Handle: Oval tapering to round
Toe Shape: Rounded




And continuing with the last of the boutique brands to appear in this thread, from another forum batmaker - Jonny @jonny77  at Scott Cricket! Being a forum batmaker, naturally I'm going to have some bias, but having also met Jonny on numerous occasions, I'll really have to do my best to stay impartial. (He's a top bloke, as many others will attest to)


So having visited Jonny's showroom a fair few times throughout the past year and a half or so (I think that long anyways), I've been able to see a steady improvement from his offerings with each visit. I reckon the vast majority of people would be happy to walk out with a bat from his workshop - the quality control is definitely there with the lower volumes produced. The finishing is of a good standard, the stock bats all seem to perform well, and the shapes are nice and attractive for the modern market. There is no compromise in the quality of handles used and also the pick ups are normally exceptional across the range of 3 shapes. And to top it off, everything is done from the raw cleft, so he can offer an in house truly custom experience.


This particular bat was obtained directly from Jonny, he had advertised this as a G2 Butterfly on Instagram. (And before anyone disagrees - http://custombats.co.uk/cbforum/index.php?topic=48951.msg779833#msg779833 - batmakers can't do much about what they're sold as G2 if there will be a small amount of butterfly thrown in) I saw it, I liked it, and basically told him to pop it aside, despite already having a bunch of customs as well from him.


This particular piece has 7 very evenly spaced and clean grains, with the butterfly stain on the face outside the main hitting area, as well as some staining on the back and on the edge. The pickup feels very balanced, with just a slither of weight felt towards the bottom. This will largely be thanks to the duckbill, concaving and also substantial wood running into the spine offsetting the mid-low swell. The JS175 is probably my favourite of the stock shapes due to the lovely low driving zone, but with great coverage in the mid-high zone. (Not a dissimilar shape to the popular SS profiles to be honest) The press feels nice out the packet - the bat does feel like it needs some knocking for sure, but not a huge amount to get ready. The thing that really stands out is the sheer size for weight - boasting a 71mm spine whilst keeping the rest of the bat substantial does take a pretty light cleft, as well as clever weight distribution.


Branding wise and the aesthetics as a whole - I am a big fan of the white with prismatic ink stickers. I just think they look classy, and the white contrasts well with the rather mild butterfly staining in this case - really bringing out the character of the willow. The stickers come with texturing and embossing, and feel of a high quality. The chevron grips used are of an excellent quality, and the toe guards Jonny uses are probably one of my favourites in the market, feeling nice and flush with the toe with a bit of give in the material. The finishing is of a high standard, but as discussed with Jonny, he isn't aiming to reach the gold standard of Salix, as it really does take a lot of time to finish a bat to that level.


All in all, a really solid stock profile from a boutique brand that is very reasonably priced, which I'm sure will appeal to many here in the UK.
« Last Edit: January 03, 2023, 10:47:08 PM by Chad »
Logged

Chad

  • World Cup Winner
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3040
  • Trade Count: (+22)
Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #10 on: January 04, 2023, 11:05:37 PM »

On the eleventh day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be... (Hold out - just one more day after this of being spammed by my rambling posts)


A GN Alpha 4 Star!


   


   





























Model: Alpha 1.0 4 Star
Willow Grade: G3
Weight: 2lb 9.6oz
Edge Max: 38mm
Spine Max: 69mm
Toe Edge: 21mm
Toe Centre: 30mm
Shoulder Edge: 14mm
Splice Depth: 38mm
Concaving: Minimal
Width: 106-107mm
Face Camber: Semi-Rounded (Approx 5mm)
Handle: Oval bottom hand, tapering to a round top hand
Toe Shape: Semi-flat (Slight rounding)


Now onto the penultimate bat on the list - a gauge busting Alpha. The Alpha was released in 2021 - and if I'm totally honest, I'm a little surprised that it stayed on instead of the Vapour. I thought that the Vapour would have been the best selling model as it had the nicer colour offerings. The Alpha is the higher middle offering out of the 2 modern ranges, which might appeal to those who hit the ball higher up on the blade, or prefer a slightly more lightweight pick up to their bat. Most of the Alphas I've felt have picked up decently, however not many were really aesthetically appealing in terms of shape. I'd probably say that of the whole Gray Nicolls range this year, the Alpha was probably my least anticipated. For my personal taste, a high middle is just not aesthetically pleasing in the vast majority of cases. (Of course, the proper Amplus bats of old are a bit of a benchmark)

This particular bat was bought from the Rochsdale branch of Romida, which happened to be my last stop before returning north of the border. They were pretty decently stocked with bats to be honest - I was a little taken aback, as I seemed to recognise the shopkeeper here - it was the same chap that had served me in the Huddersfield branch at Romida. Shopping there was pleasant - probably cause the shopkeep already knew I was a bit nuts about cricket bats - however he was perfectly attentive (Asked me if I needed any help or advice, and had a good chit chat about kit) and unattentive (Left me alone to look at bats when I said I was fine) during my visits to both branches, which made me feel like I had the freedom to be unrushed. A really pleasant shopping experience - there were even deluxe style mallets laid out for people to test bats with. (I had brought my own, but this was a welcome addition to the experience)

Despite the Alpha being my least favourite of the models, I did feel that I wanted to find one which attracted my eye, and after searching in approximately 9 stores prior to Rochsdale, there was 1 which I felt were ones which was standout. A 5 Star that I saw in All Rounder Sheffield, (pictured below) which I ummed and ah-ed over, and ultimately didn't get time to revisit before heading back up north. Luckily for me (unluckily for my wallet) Romida Rochsdale just so happened to have a standout 4 Star. Boasting a rather large spine and coverage with minimal concaving, this Alpha completely suckered me in due to the feel in the hands, coupled with the aesthetics and size. Throughout the trip, I had found many 6-8 grained bats which were just sublime - and this one was no exception, with 7 straight and clean grains with a slight wobble with that blemish on the RH outside edge just around the max swell height. The thick oval coupled with the beautiful sweeping spine were what tipped me over the edge to give my wallet a final battering on what had already become a very expensive trip. It ticked every box, including the value for money box.

Branding wise, like the Hypernova, it comes in 3 different colourways, with the 1.0 being the default White/Chrome, the 1.1 being the Metallic Blue/White themed Alpha and the 1.4 being the Red/White themed stickers. The slight update to the GN Stickers this year have been an additional row of chequers, which you can see present on the Alpha 1.4 and the Hypernova range, but not on this particular Alpha. (I'm guessing GN still have stickers left over from last year) I personally am not the biggest fan of the back stickers, they're a cool concept - make the bat look wide at the back, however there's just a bit too much going on here. Much like the Hypernova, these are high quality labels, with chrome and texturing.

All in all, definitely a good find for me, at least upon initial inspection. I would say that it is definitely a profile that seems to work, just that across the board, they didn't seem to be quite as imposing as the Hypernovas were, but perhaps that was just because I hadn't seen enough Alphas.






Logged

Chad

  • World Cup Winner
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3040
  • Trade Count: (+22)
Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #11 on: January 05, 2023, 07:28:45 PM »

On the twelfth day of Christmas the bat reviewed will be...


A GM Maxi 707!




   


   


   




























Model: Maxi 707
Willow Grade: G2/3 (With a Butterfly stain)
Weight: 2lb 9.5oz
Edge Max: 39mm
Spine Max: 61-62mm
Toe Edge: 20mm
Toe Centre: 26mm
Shoulder Edge: 14mm
Splice Depth: 38mm
Concaving: Moderate - Medium
Width: 108mm
Face Camber: Semi-round 4.5mm
Handle: Semi-oval tapering to round
Toe Shape: Rounded




Well, the last of the twelve, and what a range to end on. The Maxi is only available at Romida, alongside the Purist models. The Maxi boasts the lower middle of the 2 exclusive ranges, and comes in with the iconic yellow, blue and green colour pairing. This particular one was purchased from the Romida Hemel Hempstead store, where it narrowly beat out an 808. Luckily I had a mate with me who also went through the Maxis and Purists, and this one was the one he would pick too.


In terms of the availability of the Maxi range, all 3 Romida stores I had visited had some, as well as the Purist range. There were probably roughly 5-7 of each across the grades in each shop, but might be a good idea to call up the store just to check if you're planning on going to pick one out for yourself. They're available in the grades 707 upwards, so there's a nice bundling of price points between £210-295 before a big leap to the £420 and £580 price tags for the Original and the LE grades. For the Maxis, they were just very consistently good for me - I felt that the profile just works, and that actually made it quite difficult not to leave with another one.


This particular piece isn't exactly good looking - with 5-6 grains which are quite widely spaced and not even. There is some staining in the wood, as well as butterfly running across the back. The bat itself picks up well, with a bit of bottom heaviness to it thanks to the profile. The profile itself is very similar, if not identical to the Argon many years back, which was a favourite of mine. That low but well distributed spine profile coupled with the thick edges allowed for a large hitting zone with good power - and this particular bat certainly ticks those boxes. The response feels excellent - with that rather typical GM firmer feel but with some suppleness to it, feeling both responsive and strong/sturdy. There is practically no bow to this, something which contrasts the rather un-typically (for GM anyways) bowed blades of the Hypa, the Brava and one of the Chromas I have. I went with this one in the end due to the responsiveness, the butterfly on the back and also the price - £210 is a bit more on the premium end for a butterfly bat, however it played as well, if not better than the higher graded counterparts, and the butterfly should provide added strength for longevity.


Branding wise, I absolutely love the colourway of the Maxi - the blue and green just scream out old school GM, with the hints of yellow on the chevrons front and back and the yellow grip giving the distinctive Maxi vibes. (The lime-ish green also gives off slight Argon vibes for me too) Other than replicating the old design Maxi stickers, there isn't much GM could have done better in collaboration with Romida. The yellow grip does finish it off beautifully, and although the diamond style grip isn't my favourite, it does add to the retro style feel. (I believe it's the GM Pro Lite grip) The Purist on the other hand comes with a darker green, and maybe an ever so slightly different shade of blue. I will say for the Purist, I wish they would have went for the blue colouring for the big 'GM' sticker, or maybe even have risked it with the green rather than the black, but it does look very nice regardless.


All in all - I was very happy with my purchase - the one thing I wish is that these 2 ranges would be made available to all retailers, however I get that for the retailers who order the most, it makes business sense to keep the relationship strong with exclusive models like this.


Bonus Pics: Purist - you can see from pictures that it is pretty much an identical profile to the Noir.










Logged

Chad

Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #12 on: January 05, 2023, 07:38:20 PM »

And with that post, this concludes this year's (And possibly the last) 12 posts of Christmas! I'll update this particular post with a shortlist of brands/models that didn't make it into this - it was quite difficult to pick to be honest! I ended up omitting custom profiles and focussing solely on stock shape profiles offered, with GM and GN being probably the biggest contributors as they were what I saw most of during my trip down and back up from London. Hopefully this will give people a better idea of what to expect with this year's offering from brands, and also hopefully encourage many to actually physically go to retailers or makers to pick out your own bats when possible. Buying experience is always important - you may as well give yourself the best chance to enjoy the experience by visiting, and hopefully coming away with a brand new stick that you love. :)

I'm hoping at least some folks enjoyed reading through, and most folks didn't fall asleep while reading. Typing these out does take quite a long time as I am not the most fluent writer, and it can be quite hard to convey things in written text. Written reviews can also be quite difficult to digest, so sorry if I've contradicted anything typed, missed out anything, and also apologies for the tardiness for some of these.

And with that - the topic is now unlocked. :)




Oh, and for anyone who missed out on last year's rendition - http://custombats.co.uk/cbforum/index.php?topic=49527.0 - admittedly, it was far far far easier photographing nearly 100 bats and quickly saying something about them than doing 12 separate reviews. :-[
« Last Edit: January 05, 2023, 07:41:57 PM by Chad »
Logged

jonny77

  • International Captain
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2461
  • Trade Count: (0)
Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #13 on: January 05, 2023, 07:44:12 PM »

Great work @Chad and appreciate you writing these up and including the Butterfly from me, hopefully people enjoyed seeing the pics and the bat.

I've seen most of these bats and there were some lovely sticks in amongst them. Out of the retailers I've visited, the GNs were some of the nicer ones from the bigger boys, and Chad had some nice ones in there.
Logged

Jimbo

  • World Cup Winner
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
  • Trade Count: (+1)
Re: 12 Reviews of Christmas...
« Reply #14 on: January 05, 2023, 08:04:09 PM »

Lovely stuff as always @Chad and long may it continue (while you can be arsed 😂). Done nothing for my bat buying fever though!
Logged
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Advertise on CBF