He should have walked, yes. However Clarke should have walked in 2010. It happens, and as Strauss said earlier on Sky, that's just the game now.
Gilly was the only walker in a field of standers. Doesn't make it right, just seems acceptable in some circles.
For me personally, did take the shine off today, as when I watched them walk off, instead of looking at the scorecard and thinking bosh, we've got the buggers on the ropes, I felt Broad should be gone and we would possibly be 8/9 down.
Still, it all works itself out in the end. Never liked him anyway to be honest. Over rated.....
I digress...nice bats though