Yes the bat had to be returned to get the paypal refund.
Simple fact is i ordered a custom version of the very best bat that SF sells. The very best. And what i was sent was an absolute piece of crap. It was not made to the specs that were promised. It was not simply a matter of chopping off the top of the handle. The blade was not as short as i requested, and it picked up like a pig. I already own an sf black. This bat was not in the same class. I toyed with the idea of cutting down the blade further to help pickup but OLS were such complete douches over the whole thing i thought screw it im getting a refund and you can take back this piece of crap. I hope they've taken a loss on it.
If they had owned the mistake and been willing to open a dialogue i would have been prepared to keep the bat and work out some other deal to compensate me and allow them to not lose money.
Moral of the story is dont be a douche to your customers. Be honest and act with integrity.