Does random sporadic performances justify continued selections ? Answer yes then keep them all .. answer no.. then you have to be able to separate random innings or balls from what they produce consistently
My post was more aimed at forum mentality than actual selection. But we can go there.
Is there anyone banging down the door to play? Masses of runs county and lions ready to dive in? Then yes change the side.
If there isn’t and we are just going to go back to another player who struggled(Vince, Westley, stoneman etc) then I don’t see the point.
Let malan have a few more games or the series and if he fails completely then move on.
As for stokes replacement, everyone keeps banging on about Moeen.... sky Jd mentioned it a few times tonight.
Does he really replace stokes instantly? Do we need two spinners fornhe next year?
Or are we suggesting Ali replaces stokes and becomes th email spinner and say porter replaces Rashid to maintain 4 pace bowlers??
Me personally believe Woakes will get the call up, and the other ten will stay the same.
Author
Topic: England Vs India Test Matches (Read 169604 times)